Facilitating
Team
Nikhil Khosla, Malavika Kumaran, Nabila
Chitalwala, Devika Patel, Karishma
Khodaiji, Diya Mehta, Gaurang Poddar,
Dhvani Ghatlia, Aditi Ratho, Anvisha
Pai, Jesika Haria, Maniti Modi, Anurit
Kanti, Yash Talreja, Mohit Mandal,
Pujan Modi, Priyanka Datta
Admin Team
Anisha Wadhwa, Ayesha Mehra, Karan
Shah, Akshat Goenka, Dhruva Mahimtura,
Avinash Venkatraman, Harit Agarwal,
Pratik Sanghavi, Ambika Jayakumar
Introduction
Paigaam-Aman ka Farishta
is a student-initiative of the Dhirubhai
Ambani International School which
exemplifies youth activism. It started
off two years ago as an Indo-Pak Peace
conference and soon transcended into
a peace conference forging ties between
India and its neighboring countries
of Pakistan, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka.
This year, Paigaam-Aman ka Farishta
will look inwards, spreading the message
of peace throughout
India.
Paigaam 2009 was
held between 10th and 15th July, 2009
in a guest house in Navi Mumbai.
The Facilitating
and Administration team consisted
mainly of the students of Dhirubhai
Ambani International School and approximately
forty participants came from various
schools from different states across
the country.
The mission statement of the group
is as follows -
"Paigaam is a passionate group
of youngsters, working for a more
harmonious future. We wish to encourage
the youth to question surrounding
conflicts, widen their perspectives
and ultimately tackle conflicts of
a personal, local and global nature.
We aim for their message, their Paigaam
for peace, to then transcend all boundaries,
political and social, resulting in
a friendlier tomorrow."
The aims of the conference
were to understand the causes and
effects of past controversies; stimulate
an exchange of ideas amongst the youngsters;
encourage healthy debate; promote
teamwork; break down all stereotyping
and prejudice; and most importantly,
build long-lasting relationships with
people from across the border.
If you wish to get
involved in the group or know more,
feel free to e-mail us at
Email Address - paigaam.dais@gmail.com
Articles
written by students on their experience
in the past:
A. India-Pakistan
What comes to your
mind when you read that?
Mussharaf clasping Dr. Singh's hand?
Cricket matches?
Dramatic war movies?
Romantic. But unreal.
Sadly, the media and politics in both
India and Pakistan romanticize both
war and peace between the two nations.
We grow up in a society where Pakistani
is a swear word. We grow up watching
Gadar, Border and LOC, where our brave
Indian jawans fight 20 Pakistanis
each. We grow up in a society where
every bomb-blast, riot and militant
attack has a Pakistani hand in it.
In reality, the majority of the Indians
and Pakistanis know depressingly little
of each other and the real issues
which surround the two nations.
George Washington once said "There
is nothing so likely to produce peace
as to ready to meet the enemy."
So, armed with a gross misinterpretation
of the said quote, twenty Dhirubhai
Ambani students came together and
decided "Why not? Let's meet
the enemy!" And thus we set out
with the death-wish of bringing together
Indian and Pakistani teenagers and
giving them an opportunity to reassess
the clichés and stereotypes
they carried all their lives.
With the full support of the school
administration and after six long
months of pleading with visa officers
in New Delhi, running off in every
break to make calls to Pakistani schools,
putting together a minutely planned
timetable for the week, confirming
and rereconfirming arrivals and departures
of participants coming from eight
different cities, it was the eve of
Paigaam.
We had put together a highly explosive
mélange of thirty fiercely
patriotic young adults from all over
India and Pakistan who were armed
with months of research and resolved
to prove that Kashmir truly belonged
to them.
The first thing we told the shocked
group of participants was that they
were free to hate the other country?
only if the opinion was truly their
own, formed after evaluating neutral
facts, discussing and interacting
with youngsters across the border.
They had to rid themselves of the
opinions they had inculcated from
their history books and fanatical
political propaganda. We wanted them
to unload the painful experiences
that our ancestors handed down to
us and start afresh. They had to form
their own opinion.
And thus started a vigorous week of
activities, discussions and games
which came to a productive yet unnaturally
quick end on the 16th of June.
But we went back
with a message. We went back with
an understanding that loving Pakistan
and loving India are not two sides
of a coin - you don't have to pick.
You don't have to be at the border
to prove your love for the country.
Befriending the 'enemy' can be patriotic.
So, meet the enemy we did.
Not on a battlefield,
as soldiers. Not in a stimulated conference,
as politicians.
But in a guest house in Navi Mumbai,
as representatives of humanity. As
friends.
Under the snowy mountains
of Switzerland ? On the rocky cliffs
of Colorado ? On the skyscraper at
Manhattan ? Forget that! These forty
young Indians and Pakistanis chose
to spend their first week of summer
at a conference set at a Guest House
in Navi Mumbai! With a strong delegation
of twenty-six adolescent Indians and
Pakistanis, and a facilitating team
of twenty students from Dhirubhai
Ambani International School, “Paigaam”
was a unique conference about the
relations of India and Pakistan, aimed
at developing an everlasting friendship
between the youth of the two nations.
Filled with lots of enjoyable activities,
furious debates and more importantly,
a youth dedicated to a better and
more peaceful future, Paigaam was
a memorable experience for all those
involved.
Scene
1, Take 1: Paigaam's beginning
Finally, on 10 th
June, the six month-long preparation
of Paigaam was put to test when the
eighteen Indians and eight Pakistani
students arrived. On 11 th June, the
momentous beginning of this impressive
conference took place and Paigaam
was unveiled. What really was Paigaam?
Was it an MUN? No! Was it a chance
to blame the other nation? No! Was
it a chance to solve the conflict
between the two nations? No! We couldn't
expect twenty-six 16 year-olds to
resolve an issue that has been a quandary
for the two nations' leaders for over
fifty years. This conference had as
its aims ideas which went beyond the
stereotypical peace conferences -
we wanted to stimulate an exchange
of ideas amongst the youngsters, promote
teamwork, build trust among one another
and most importantly build long-lasting
relationships with people from across
the border. And on this note, the
week at Paigaam began. Each activity
was carefully created with the aim
of being exuberant, yet having a strong
message to it (bias, stereotyping,
compromise, etc. - issues very pertinent
to the Indo-Pak conflict), which the
participants came to realize towards
the end of each activity.
Scene
2, Take 1: The two governments meet
One of the most interesting
activities was the role-play. The
Indians and Pakistanis were mixed
and split into two groups, one representing
the Indian government, and one the
Pakistani government. Each participant
represented a minister of that nation.
The governments were given three hours
to come to a compromise over the Kashmir
issue. The quality of debate was unimaginable,
and the passion with which Indians
spoke on behalf of the Pakistani government
and vice-versa, really captured the
essence of Paigaam. Finally, after
a furious debate of two hours, a lot
of dedication and some compromise,
the two sides came to a consensus.
Scene
3, Take 1: Cricket match
The ultimate paradox
- the passion for this sport unites
the two nations and divides it. And
what better way to end the conference
than to epitomize this paradox with
some friendly rivalry? The last day
of Paigaam saw green and blue jerseys
fluttering about, bowling, batting
and fielding in an exclusive Indo-Pak
cricket match. But there was a catch
- it wasn't Indians vs Pakistanis;
we felt the best way to exemplify
our “Paigaam” was to let
Indians step into Pakistanis' shoes
and vice-versa. This activity characterized
all our aims - teamwork, trust-building,
and more importantly, the best and
most amusing way to punctuate the
end of the week.
Only the week had
ended, not our striving or determination.
This conference has been the most
unforgettable experience of my life,
and I left, having made some of the
best friends of my life and with the
realization that such conferences
can really help break the stereotypes
about the other nation that our generations
are growing up with. We hope that
our ?Paigaam? continues to be spread
all across the world, with conferences
much larger than Paigaam ?07, and
is extended to include not just India
and Pakistan, but Bangladesh, China
and Nepal as well.
-
Mehek Punatar
- “A
Dream not followed, is a dream
not worth dreaming”
This was what my
dad said one night, that made me so
dejected. So many problems on the
mind…Visa still not done…
funds not enough… no sponsors
yet …communication problems
with some schools. It seemed that
the youth peace conference some of
my classmates and I were organizing
was now nearly impossible to hold.
It was an Indo-Pak conference where
we wanted youth from both nations
to interact. Though the theme was
future peace proposals on Kashmir
issue, the basic aim was to understand
each other's culture and ‘break
the stereotypes' which we have been
making since the time of partition.
Sounds clichéd?
Well then, what makes
this initiative different from the
numerous others “peace organizations”
ones that have been launched between
India and Pakistan since 2000? The
answer was simple. There is a vast
difference between negotiating for
peace and peace culminating through
understanding and caring. A difference
between diplomats and friends. One
of the biggest human drawbacks is
trying to bury or minimize the problem,
rather than finding the root-cause
of it, be it a misunderstanding, baseless
prejudice, or ego issue. It has been
a well-known belief that ‘Youth
of Today' are the ‘Leaders of
Tomorrow' and the problems around
the globe will be up to them to solve.
With this thought, we wanted to spark
a deep-rooted understanding and friendship
as a basic platform for further co-operation,
which can spread tomorrow.
This understanding made my friends
and I work for a year to make ‘Paigaam
'07' a success. We decided to bring
together a group of young minds across
India and Pakistan from diverse background
through a selection process. The idea
was not to have a ‘summit' where
delegates of both countries put their
points across, but to have series
of informal ‘activities' and
games, through which we could make
them understand the problems from
both countries' perspective and ‘get
the bigger picture'. It was tough.
We had neither any idea of visa process
nor had any experience dealing with
governments and with the sensitive
diplomatic situation between the two
nations, it seemed very difficult.
Already a similar conference last
year (of which some of us were participants)
could not get Pakistani delegates
visa, making us a little more skeptical
of reaching our goal.
It was around that
time, one night, that my dad's words
struck me. He was right. We needed
to think and plan our work. We could
not ‘crib' and do nothing. Yes,
it was going to be difficult, but
not impossible. Just a few days later,
a ray of hope was seen through these
dark, cloudy times. One of the participants
of the last conference helped us get
through the governmental procedures
in Delhi. Our Chairperson and the
school Administration supported us
strongly. It seemed now everything
was just going to be the way we planned.
Right, now we needed to get on with
the timetable during the conference,
but due to the SAT's and exams-infested
May, everything became stagnant for
the month. It was only after the end
of the month that we met regularly,
planned and checked every detail.
The actual conference
was itself much more than words can
describe it. Every moment of it was
worth the effort put in. Even as a
facilitator, I got to learn so much
from it. We made friends there; friends
from different cities and nations,
but friends for life, making the other
things insignificant. It is difficult
to express exactly what the feeling
was. Misquoting Morpheus from The
Matrix, “No one can really tell
you what Paigaam is, you have to feel
it to know it.” All I can say
is the End here DID justify the Means.
Oscar Wilde once said, “Happiness
makes up in height what it lacks in
length”. He was right. I felt
that Happiness for those short five
days and I think the mark of it is
going to be left throughout my life.
- Anupriya Kanti
Pakistani Participant
- Kinza Naqvi
On 9th June 2007,
nine patriotic and fervent Pakistanis
landed at Chatrapati Shivaji International
Airport, Mumbai. Ostensibly, feeling
a little out of place, we headed outside
to find ourselves drown in a plethora
of people. A familiar voice grasped
my attention and the speck of alienation
vanished upon seeing three adolescents
waving and smiling warmly at us. After
a short introduction, we got into
impeccably luxurious cars, swooshed
through the roads of Navi Mumbai and
halted at Dhirubhai Ambani International
School . Relaxation, chit-chats, touring
Dhirubhai Ambani International School
and contenting our growling tummies
were the core reasons for two hours'
stay there.
Around six-thirty,
we arrived at the beautiful and comfortable
guest house. On our way back, I chatted
with one of the security guards and
we were pretty glad and surprised
to know how much our culture, language,
accent and dresses are in common.
Paigaam's logo comprising
Pakistan and India's flags complimented
by a dove; symbolizing ‘peace',
was a replenishing sight and made
me realize that the conference was
taking place for real - a gigantic
triumph indeed, after hard work for
six months!
The next day, we left for ‘Mumbai
Darshan.' A visit to a Hindu temple
was indeed very interesting and informative.
We also went to the Prince of Wales
Museum, Bombay Chowpatti, Gateway
of India, Taj Mahal Hotel, Juhu beach,
Jehangir Art Gallery and a few shopping
malls.
The much-awaited
11th June arrived and the grand conference
commenced with oozing fervour and
hype. At 8.30 am, the Club House was
buzzing with laughter and muffled
voices. Kick-starting, we wrote self-realization
letters to jot down our sincere view
points about Indians, Pakistanis and
Indo-Pak relations over sixty years.
These letters were sealed and later
compared with freshly written self-realization
letters on 15th of June. The results
varied astoundingly!
Next, we proceeded
with a few trust-building and conflict-management
activities which consequently educated
us to trust and help each other despite
belonging to different races and religions,
esteem each others' views and most
notably, come to a mutual conciliation
after debating over rusty and typical
issues.
‘War and Peace'
directed by Mr. Anand Patwardan and
‘Making of a Muslim terrorist'
were controversial, agitating and
debatable movies that we watched.
They were followed by a question-answer
session as Mr. Patwardan was invited
to confer with forty-four of us. Undeniably,
it was an attention-grabbing discussion!
The next morning,
we clad formally for three hours'
grand conference. Indians and Pakistanis
were mingled together and allotted
posts of different ministers, Presidents
and Prime Ministers of India and Pakistan.
Also, one Pakistani and Indian acted
as representatives of Liberals for
Kashmir (LFK). It was more like a
Model United Nation that welled up
diverse opinions, rejuvenated former
buried problems and resulted in a
heated debate. Proceeding, the Defence
Ministers of the respective countries
coordinated and drafted a resolution
that was acceptable to India, Pakistan
and Kashmir ..
Furthermore, History
text-book writing proved to be one
of the most engaging activities. The
Pakistanis realized that instruments
of accession don't even exist in their
text books. Also, the Indians knew
very little about the plebiscite that
according to the Pakistanis could
prove to be an easy victory to get
Kashmir.
Indo-Pak cricket
matches have certainly been the talk
of the town! Similarly, the Paigaamis
plunged into the zeal of four cricket
matches, sprinkled by doses of revitalizing
commentary from one of the facilitators.
Both the countries' national anthems
were sung before opening the cricket
match. Indeed, it was great fun!
A treasure-hunt was
a profusely strenuous activity that
dealt with exploring renowned cities
of India and Pakistan through a number
of clues - the final destination being
Kashmir. The winning team was blindfolded
and blessed with buckets of cold water,
to kill the exhaustion after an hour
of striving to reach Kashmir.
A farewell dance
party was thrown on 15th June to live
up and savour the last few hours together.
Moreover, we drew our hand-prints
on pieces of pink and white paper
that were embellished with friendship
messages, to be treasured forever.
Undoubtedly, it was an experience
of a lifetime and I pray that such
triumphant exchange programs promoting
peace, harmony and friendship between
the two countries continue to happen
in the near future. Live long Paigaam!
Pakistani Participant
- Nida Sohail Chaudary
I entered Mumbai
on Saturday the 9th of June 2007,
at 12:45 pm Indian Standard Time.
I was entering the land of my “enemies”,
entering the land that I, like thousands
of other Pakistanis, had been brought
up to loathe. I was extremely skeptical
as to the treatment that I would get,
I had my doubts regarding the immigration
process and all with due reason as
it had taken me a year alone to muster
a 10-day visa after several rejections.
Yet I was a girl
on a mission. I had come to erase
the invisible boundaries of hatred
that separated the people of our respective
nations; I had come to understand
these ‘Indians' who for me were
a myth, represented only by biased
politicians or over dramatic ‘soaps'.
I had come to be a change!
I came to India to
participate in a week-long peace conference
known as PAIGAAM (ironically sharing
its name with Al-Qaeeda's Hindu-Muslim
conversion drive in India ), organized
by Dhirubhai Ambani International
School . The tagline for which was
“Angel of Peace” and the
main topic of discussion being Kashmir.
For one week all
of us took part in several activities
which not only changed our view points
regarding the Kashmir Issue, but made
us better human beings. This conference
taught us not only diplomacy and persuasive
augmenting, but more important lessons
such as making a certain situation
beneficial for all, like learning
to sacrifice for the greater good,
it taught us how it feels to be labeled
and blindly misled. But on a personal
note it taught me an immensely important
lesson and that is that these ‘people'
living across the border are not another
classification of human, nor are they
to be held responsible for the mistakes
and actions of their leaders in the
past and present; but they are as
much like me and the other Pakistanis
as they can possibly be.
Because of PAIGAAM
I have made the greatest friends I
could ever make. I found such love
and friendship in India that it was
beyond my imagination. And I speak
for the entire Pakistani delegation
when I say that these bonds of love
and friendship that we have formed
with the Indians in a matter of seven
days are ones that can never be corrupted
by political or military tensions!
I have come to realize that the main
causes of this unexplained rivalry
between our great nations are not
only the personal grievances of our
ancestors, who brainwash us from childhood,
but also the media which portrays
the people from across the border
as some kind of extra-terrestrials
living only on their thirst for “revenge”
against the other. And the history
textbooks alongside our history teachers,
who instead of teaching the facts,
impart such biased knowledge that
a student becomes prejudiced against
their neighbor.
I departed from India
on Saturday the 16th of June, 2007,
at 2:30 pm Indian Standard Time. I
was leaving the land where I had made
the greatest of friends; a land that
I now loved…
| |
|
| Dates:
|
10 th July
- 15 th July, 2009
|
| |
|
| Venue :
|
‘Retreat’
Guesthouse, Ghansoli,
Navi Mumbai |
| |
|
| Organisors
& Facilitators:
|
Students
of Yr. 10 and 11 of
DAIS |
| |
|
| Supervisors:
|
Ms. Mou Maiti,
Mr. Yasir Choonawala,
Ms. Sunita Nath
|
| |
|
| Teacher Support:
|
Mr. Sunil
Makwana, Ms. Suneet
Gandhi, Mr. Bipin Shah,
Mrs. Swarnalata Potukuchhi,
Mr. Chanchal Singh,
Mr.
Edward Bantrywhite,
Mr. Rajesh, Mr. Narendra
Shetty, Colonel Bhandari,
Mrs. Soma Basu, Mr.
Abhimanyu Basu
|
| |
|
| Programme
schedule:
|
As enclosed
in the following pages.
|
| |
|
| Special mention:
|
A
special mention of
our Guest Speaker,
Mr. Rakyesh Omprakash
Mehra who shared his
invaluable experiences
and knowledge with
the students.
Also, our heartfelt
gratitude towards
Mrs. Nita Ambani and
Mr. Dermot Keagan. |
Last, but definitely
NOT the least ? are our wonderful
Yr. 10 and 11 students.
The students have done a
brilliant job of planning,
programming and executing
the
Programme. EVERYTHING has
been handled by the students
- from choosing the menu,
to allotting rooms to the
students, planning the activites,
organizing the seminars etc
…A
big kudos to all of them!
Time
|
Friday
10 th July |
Saturday
11 th July |
Sunday
12 th July |
Monday
13 th July |
Tuesday
14 th July |
8
am - 9 am |
NA
|
Breakfast
|
Breakfast
|
Breakfast
|
Breakfast
|
9
am - 9.30 am |
NA
|
Apocalpyse |
Debates |
Jones
& Miller |
Cricket
Match |
9.30
am -
10 am |
NA |
10
am -
10.30 am |
NA |
Submarine
Game |
|
Trip
Around
Bombay |
| 10.30
am - 11 am |
NA |
11
am -
12 noon |
NA |
Role
- play |
"Making
of
Terrorist video +
Discussion" |
12
noon -
1 pm |
Arrival
+ Lunch |
1
pm -
1.30 pm |
Settling
into rooms.
Free time. |
|
|
1.30
pm -
2 pm |
Lunch |
Lunch |
2
pm -
2.30 pm |
Introduction
to
PAIGAAM +
making of
PAIGAAM +
National Anthem |
|
Lunch |
2.30
pm -
3 pm |
Circle
Of Trust |
Guest
Speaker |
Cricket
Match |
3
pm -
3.30 pm |
Self
Letters +
Learning Names |
Conflict
Management |
3.30
pm -
4 pm |
4
pm -
4.30 pm |
Labelling
and
Stereotypes |
Begginning
of the
Amazing Race.
Teams given out,
instructions given,
rules etc. |
Continuation
of the
Amazing Race |
Rest |
4.30
pm -
5 pm |
5
pm -
5.30 pm |
JAM
(Just A
Minute) |
Message
+ Writing |
5.30
pm -
6 pm |
Media
Game |
Reflections |
6
pm -
6.30 pm |
Secret
-telling |
Time
for Practice |
6.30
pm -
7 pm |
Human
Barometer |
XY
Game |
Performance |
7
pm -
7.30 pm |
Relaxing
time
before dinner |
Time
to practice for
Performance |
7.30
pm -
8.30 pm |
Dinner |
Dinner |
Dinner |
Dinner |
8.30
pm -
9 pm |
Reflection
Group |
Reflection
Group |
Reflection
Group |
Reflection
Group |
Party
from now
onwards.. |
9.00
pm -
10 pm |
Free
Time |
Free
Time |
Night
Football |
|
PAIGAAM
– AMAN KA FARISHTA
(Click here to view photos) |